Category: January 2021
Suniti Sanghavi: Jan 25 – Jan 29, 2021
Jan 25: Day 1 of my fast, day 336 of our chain.
I had to step in today, because a new volunteer who had signed up for this slot sounded exhausted when I spoke to them earlier, in the middle of a work trip. They had fallen asleep before being able to post, and were glad to have me take over this time, even though they are eager to join us again as soon as they have been able to decompress a bit.
Thanks to our different time zones, I hadn’t eaten anything today, and was able to take over smoothly without a loss of continuity for our fasting chain. This really drives home how stretched all of us are sometimes as we balance our different roles and priorities. And yet, depriving oneself of food for 5 days straight to express one’s dissent makes sense for perfectly normal people. Just how tone-deaf must the leadership of India be for such extreme measures to feel justified to so many of us?
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah
Jan 26: Day 2 of my fast, day 337 of our chain.
Today, the 71st anniversary of the Constitution of independent India, revealed how prepared the BJP Government is to gaslight, sabotage and vilify its own people when they cannot fall in line with its demands. I woke up to news of the Government insinuating an anti-secular Khalistan nexus on the protesting farmers because they had hoisted a Nishan Sahib flag on the Red Fort.
Two things:
1. Our armed forces ceremoniously hoist the Nishan Sahib in all their cantonments. If our Government ever paid attention to our jawans, it would have known that this wasn’t a Khalistani flag. So why did the Government and the media allow for such mischief?
2. The protesting farmers were blamed for being un-secular, and for violating the sanctity of the Red Fort and the Indian tricolor. Really? Can anyone level that charge against any group in India today before first pointing a finger at the BJP?
The next outrage was a BJP-supporting actor called Deep Sindhu wearing a fake turban and infiltrating groups of Sikh farmers to make uncharacteristically inflammatory speeches.
Again:
1. Is the Government planting moles within its own people to provoke and incriminate them?
2. Is this how they created Godhra? What is real with this Government, and what is yet another of its evil genocidal tricks?
Finally (to my limited knowledge), there was the incident of a Delhi public transport bus blocking the route the protesting farmers had obtained official permission for. The farmers were accused of vandalism, when video footage showed them skillfully using their tractors to gingerly move the empty bus out of the way.
Again, a trap was laid for them in full Machiavellian glory:
1. Rumors were spread amongst the farmers to start earlier at 9 am instead of their officially assigned time to march at noon. Such last minute planning lapses are commonplace in India, and no one can be blamed for mistaking the rumors to be true.
2. As they proceeded, there was the offending bus parked for no apparent reason in the middle of the way. If this wasn’t a trap to create an appearance of violence and vandalism on the part of innocent farmers, what was it?
It just gets dirtier and dirtier every passing day with these criminals masquerading as our elected officials, and this Republic Day was a landmark for their evil political games. A populist Government knows that it can lure a favored group into blind compliance by promising them big rewards for free. Rewards for simply putting away their critical thinking capabilities. With a powerful majority out of their way, what’s to stop the powers-that-be from turning the rest of the country into an animal farm, whose inhabitants can be treated as little more than items for eventual consumption…
Wake up, India! Any hope for the survival of our nation depends on those of us who are still sentient enough to recognize this government as an evil pack of criminals. We need to ward off this Government’s constant attempts to divide us when it isn’t busy breaking us. Let us summon all the mutual tolerance and interpersonal largesse that we can find in ourselves to make sure that we recognize our true enemy and *unite* against it! Once the monster has been vanquished, there will be much more time and energy left for nuanced debate and much-needed reform! But for now, let us put our differences aside and simply unite against the train-wreck this government is leading us to!
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah
Jan 27: Day 3 of my fast, day 338 of our chain:
As I put up with the discomfort of food deprivation today, it strikes me that Navreet Singh, the 25-year old newlywed farmer who was crushed to death yesterday as he lost control of his tractor after being shot in the eye with a tear gas canister, isn’t eating anything either. And never will. His family and friends will be deprived forever of his precious presence in their midst.
For what? For the vanity and selfishness of one man whose idea of law and order is forcing complete obedience to his every word, whose policies alternate between infantile cluelessness and an infinite capacity to inflict grievous harm on others? A man whose political messaging is as hollow as his vision for the nation, shaped only by greed, lies and ridiculous games of dress-up?
We don’t deserve this! Out with this cold-blooded, authoritarian, parasitic government!!
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah
Jan 28: Day 4 of my fast, day 339 of our chain:
The standoff between the Modi Government and farmers from all over India seems to have reached epic proportions now. The farmers, under the leadership of Rakesh Tikait have declared this as a struggle unto death.
Is the Government going to blame this discontent on the Muslims? Is it going to blame it on the Congress? Will the farmers – 60% of our population – buy the Government’s constant lies like the bhakts do?
Doesn’t look like it! The sleeping giant of India has arisen! The Emperor is looking more and more naked every passing day.
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah
Jan 29: Day 5 of my fast, day 340 of our chain:
With the exception of having brought the rotting scum of our society in clear view of everyone (including myself) to whom it was a mystery, the Modi Government has failed. Not only is Modi an indelible blemish on India, but the RSS, like a swarm of locusts, has left behind destruction – social, moral, economic – of a magnitude that will take us generations to recover from. Modi must go! And the RSS must be banned with its members put under close surveillance!!
Legally, though, our hands appear to be tied. I welcome differing insights and opinions, but reaching out to more and more people and educating them about the importance of the Lok Sabha leaders they put in office seems to be the only constitutionally viable alternative:
1. As of July 2019, 27 no-confidence motions have been moved. Prime Minister Indira Gandhi faced the most no confidence motions, fifteen, followed by Lal Bahadur Shastri and P. V. Narasimha Rao (three each), Morarji Desai (two) and Jawaharlal Nehru, Rajiv Gandhi, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, Narendra Modi (one each). Atal Bihari Vajpayee lost the no confidence motion by a margin of 1 vote (269-270) in April 1999. Prime Minister Desai resigned on 12 July 1979. The most recent no confidence motion against the Narendra Modi government was accepted by the Lok Sabha speaker, but was defeated by 325–115. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_of_no_confidence)
2. With the Anti-defection law (India), the vote of no confidence has no relevance when the majority party has an absolute majority in the House. If the party with an absolute majority in the House issues a whip to party members to vote in favor of the Government, then it is impossible to remove the Government by a no confidence motion. Hence the no confidence exercise of the House (Lok Sabha) merely becomes a no confidence exercise of the Party. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_of_no_confidence)
3. At present, the BJP and its allies have a firm majority in the Lok Sabha, with a total of 335 seats against an opposition count of 204 and 4 vacancies. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lok_Sabha)
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah

Protected: Nitin Vohra: Jan 20 – Jan 24, 2021
Protected: Priyadarshini Ohol: Jan 15 – Jan 19, 2021
Protected: Manpreet Singh: Jan 10 – Jan 14, 2021
Protected: Rashmi Menon: Jan 5 – Jan 9, 2021
Suniti Sanghavi: Dec 31, 2020 – Jan 4, 2021
Dec 31: Day 1 of my fast, day 311 of our chain.
I have been swamped with work deadlines all through the holidays this December, and today is going to be no different – thankfully, Christian is sailing in the same boat (ah, the perks of sharing your line of work with your spouse!) and Neal is easygoing as ever!
What of 2020 in hindsight? Here’s a short list:
1. COVID forced us to reassess our priorities. I called home to check on my parents much more frequently than ever. It is a precious connection I would otherwise not have appreciated enough.
2. COVID helped us cross our imagined boundaries. I spent most of my life seeing professional work and political engagement in binary terms – it was either one or the other. I now know that both can be done at once. Science and democratic values go hand in hand.
3. COVID taught us to care for people in spite of their distance from us, both literally and figuratively. It drew us away from narrow tribalism and strengthened our sense of solidarity towards each other. Solidarity feels increasingly like a vaccine that helps us achieve a herd-immunity against evil. It is the most wholesome way of being I have ever known, and has absolutely nothing to do with self-sacrifice.
Happy New Year! Let’s make it a good one!! ❤️
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah

Jan 1: Day 2 of my fast, day 312 of our chain.
The past year in India has been a time of nonstop upheaval. After Kashmiris, liberal arts students, Muslims, migrant workers, and political dissenters of all hues, farmers find themselves at the center of our latest crisis. I can’t write with any authority about the farmer’s protest: having grown up in Mumbai, I have very little grasp of the core issues. I would only make a mockery of their suffering if I claimed to ever speak on their behalf.
What little I do understand is this: the Modi government, with its “impeccable record” in implementing structural change (as proven by demonetization, GST, NRC-CAA, and the nationwide COVID lockdown of March 2020), wishes to bring structural reform to our farmers by removing the minimal safeguards currently in place to ensure that farmers earn a fair price for their toil. Modi wishes to unleash on our farmers a brutal, purely profit-driven, free market economy mediated by “scrupulous” capitalists like Ambani and Adani.
It is understandable, even for someone as clueless about farming as me, that our farmers fear for their security. Farmer suicides account for 11.2% of all suicides in India. The rates at which our farmers have been committing suicides in states like Maharashtra and Karnataka is alarming (https://www.livemint.com/…/the-geography-of-farmer…, https://thewire.in/agriculture/farmer-suicides-data). Our farmers suffer from poor infrastructure (bad rural roads and irrigation, lack of efficient farming equipment and cold storage facilities), bad debts, and the lack of a meaningful safety net in a profession that is exposed more than any other to the vagaries of nature. All this results not only in low agricultural productivity but also in the Indian farmer receiving a considerably smaller fraction (10% to 23%) of the national consumer price than in developed countries (64% to 81%), the difference going to losses, inefficiencies and middlemen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agriculture_in_India). Agriculture employs 59% of our total workforce, while accounting for only ~23% of our GDP (http://www.fao.org/india/fao-in-india/india-at-a-glance/en).
A benevolent and competent government would be moved by these numbers to recognize farmers’ issues and elevate them to a high national priority. Rehabilitation measures would involve infrastructural reform, debt relief and the provision of re-education opportunities for small and marginal farmers who are tethered to the profession merely for the lack of safe alternatives.
But the Modi government is neither benevolent nor competent. All it has ever done is ignore the needy, and when those suffering get too clamorous, Modi and Shah, like Mr. Burns of the Simpsons, just “release the hounds.” Or wolves, in this case, like Adani and Ambani.
No Indian deserves such treason from its own elected Government, especially not the Indians who toil to feed us. So, in spite of not possessing a single farmer’s bone in my body, I stand with our farmers in solidarity and dedicate my fast today to their struggle.
#StandWithFarmers
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah

Jan 2: Day 3 of my fast, day 313 of our chain.
Today, I’d like to take a moment to thank Facebook for giving me friends who are my friends not just as a result of physical proximity, nostalgia, or family ties, but are people I can truly connect with. In particularly, I’d like to thank Agnivo Gosai for posting this article (https://www.wired.co.uk/…/mrna-coronavirus-vaccine…) about Katalin Kariko, who has been at the helm of Biontech’s mRNA Covid vaccine, but who, in 1995, struggled against the greatest odds to secure funding for research she felt was important. As I sit in my corner, slogging away on grant proposals while the whole world seems to be celebrating their holidays, it is nice to know I’m not alone.
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah
Jan 3: Day 4 of my fast, day 314 of our chain.
Yesterday, I was thankful for the relative normalcy of my post. After all that we have been through during the past year, I felt a sense of respite, and hoped BJP supporters were finally sobering up. Alas, that was just wishful thinking, and I was shaken back to reality early this morning, as I saw a video of peacefully protesting farmers in Haryana being bombarded from a distance with tear gas bombs late in the evening in the cover of darkness. Will we ever get to know who was behind this dastardly attack on lawfully protesting farmers?
As if that wasn’t disturbing enough, a dear Muslim friend in Indore, one of the strongest, most fearless, kind, and brilliant people I know, said she and her family were in a state of alarm after noisy rallies in her neighborhood by BJP supporters, accompanied by the police, who went around demanding donations for building the Ram Temple in Ayodhya. From a Muslim perspective, I cannot imagine a worse manner of adding insult to deep injury, the worst kind of injustice imaginable.
Just four days back, similar pro-BJP mobs had desecrated a mosque in the city, loudly chanting Hindu slogans while namaaz was being offered inside the mosque. The media is already demonizing Muslims for stone-pelting in retaliation. Why is no one saying anything about the cruel humiliation and deliberate provocation they are being subjected to? Am I supposed to feel proud of belonging to a religion that menaces and threatens my dear friend and her community for no sensible reason?
I am on edge as she is. For her safety, well being and peace of mind. I want her to live with the same pride and self-confidence that I would want for myself. Instead, I fear that she will forever be scarred by what she and her community are being subjected to. We have already seen Hindus wash their hands off humanity in Gujarat in 2002 and in Northeast Delhi in February last year. It would be foolhardy not to feel threatened in Indore as a Muslim.
Hindus will carry an unbearable burden of guilt, shame, and bad karma if we don’t correct course soon. My shame feels bottomless. Pained, revolted, and woefully helpless about what my friend, my sister, is being put through…
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah
Jan 4: Day 5 of my fast, day 315 of our chain.
There are times I catch myself being terrified of things that aren’t Earth-shattering but which I find disturbing to imagine anyway. Things that are trivial, even laughable, and often imaginary actually, like the thought of being rejected by a random stranger over a misunderstanding. They continue to command my thoughts until I call myself out for the imaginary bullsh*t I entertain to support my flawed narrative.
Which makes me wonder: what are the imaginary fears authoritarian leaders around the world get attached to that drive their thirst for power? Do they realize that their fears compel them to commit blind acts of violence that make them dependent on power to merely survive? Do they even leave themselves the choice of imagining an alternative?
What are the fears behind a billionaire’s drive to accumulate wealth beyond any mortal human’s needs? Don’t they realize that they are condemning their children to a life of superfluousness, depriving them of the meaningfulness that makes life so sweet to live? Do they ever pause to think of an alternative to the golden cages they have willingly locked themselves in?
What makes fundamentalists so fearful of their beliefs being questioned? Why does it feel so dangerous for them to step out of their imagined order? What storm do they think rages “out there”?
These questions make me incredibly thankful for the times I went out on a limb and tried something unknown and unexpected. Those were the probably the only times I was in true possession of all my senses, and those were the times that truly enriched my life.
I bring my fast to an end today with the hope that we can try every now and then to break free of the prisons of our fearful imaginations, and give reality a chance to surprise us. In hindsight, our most fearless choices may prove to be a lot more pleasant than we imagined.
#ChainFastingForPeace #FastingAgainstFascism #ResignAmitShah

